Saturday, May 5, 2007

So, do you really need your irons to be different lengths?

Over the last 16 years, I have mostly played a set of Tommy Armour 845s that have been really good to me. During my college days when I was striking the ball well, I used my dad's old set of Wilson Staff blades. I loved the workability of the blades, but lack of practice really punished me after a while and forced me to regress back to the cavity back 845s. Over the years, my swing has really gotten more aggresive with a later wrist release, so I started over drawing the ball almost 12-15 yards. Last year, I really started thinking about buying a new set of irons. I went to a lot of demo days...to the point that every time I saw the Mizuno rep, he knew me by name. My favorite set seemed to be the Mizuno MP-60s, but it really wasn't a significant enough improvement for me to justify spending $900 on them. My final decision was to experiment a little, and I had my first taste of clubmaking by reshafting and regrooving my 845s. During that time, I started digging around on the internet and found some really great resources for equiment information and reviews as well as custom clubmaking.
Through my reseach, I discovered a swelling controversy on eliminating the graduated length of irons throughout the set. The practice of increasing lengths in clubs throughout the set has been around almost as long as the game itself. The general premise is based on the fact that a larger swing arc will increase the speed of the clubhead, therefore transferring that extra energy into the golf ball to increase its force (and distance). Loft variances between clubs are also used to control the distance plus trajectory. Between these two variables, pioneering clubmakers figured out a way to create a consistent shot dispersion between clubs. Now remember, up until 70 years ago, clubs were handmade with wood and steel and very difficult to generate swing speeds of even amateurs of today. Therefore, any slight increase in clubhead speed that could be gained by a larger arc had a greater percentage increase in distance compared to the faster average swing speeds of today.
With the advancement in materials and technology of today, we have the tools to take the characteristics of an individual swing and build clubs to better fit a certain swing plane and vary the distance and trajectory of clubs through loft, club weighting, and shaft bend characteristics. It is now perceivable that graduating the club length could effect the consistency in ball striking (which also affects distance) more than the net gain from a larger swing arc.
When I mentioned this concept to friend of mine, nicknamed the Hat, he told me that he has thought about the concept of having the same length for irons for a few years. Little did he know that it wasn't an original idea. In fact, Tommy Armour came out with a set based on the concept in the 80's called EQLs. The concept really didn't catch on at that time, but another company formed in the 90's call 1 Iron Golf. They have really led the march for the single length concept, and their website has plenty of testimonials from "born again" golfers. Recently a component company, PureFit, started making a set of iron clubheads that were weighted the same rather than the traditional weight change to compensate for the longer shaft to match swingweight. (Component companies specialize in building parts for custom clubmaking rather than the manufacturers that sell assembled clubs.)
The Hat just bought some new Callaway X-20's a few weeks ago, so he made his old set of Ping I3's a single length set. He's only played with them a couple of times, but I can tell you that his favorite club in the set is now his 4 iron. I'm sure that stems from the gratification of his new found ball striking consistency with the shorter club, but it says a lot for the concept. He says that he hits it about 1/2 club shorter than with the traditional length, but his consistency has justified the loss of yardage. Personally, I have no problem giving up 6-8 yards per club if I could hit the ball closer to the hole and give my putter a chance more often.
We are now on a mission to build a "prototype" set with the PureFit heads and Rifle Flighted shafts and see the differences when the swingweight is consistent. To me, it is logical that the same set up for each iron will promote an identical swing plane from club to club, but you should never underestimate the underlying psychology of the fundamental change in equipment. After hitting a 7 iron XXX yards, I can see how stepping up with a 4 iron of the same length would challenge your ingrained feel that you need to swing harder to get the ball to the target.
I will probably receive the parts on May 10th, so I should be able to build them by the weekend and provide feedback the week following. Stay tuned as I journal the experiment, and please provide your thoughts on the subject.

Monday, April 30, 2007

My first post!

Well, I have thought about starting a blog for a long time, and I just made the commitment to start. I can't promise that there will be consistent posting, but I can promise that there will be great content when I do post. Topics will include technology in the business and at home as well as some infrequent comments about golf theory, equipment, and the PGA. I will be posting lots of links to different articles that I find interesting, and I will also post reference links for different subject matter. There will always be an opportunity to post comments, so please opine!